"Coffey's collaboration in the difficult piano score added immeasurably to the overall success. It would be difficult to imagine a better performance."
   -   Recital with Finnish baritone Jorma Hynninen

"This concert turned out to be an evening of glorious music-making. We were treated to an artist in his prime [Jorma Hynninen] assisted most ably by pianist Melinda Coffey, whose solid musicianship and pianistic flair helped make this evening such an artistic triumph."
   -   Recital with Finnish baritone Jorma Hynninen

"This was an evening for Melinda Coffey to shine. It was a true star turn, spotlighting her piano virtuosity, informational depth, and appealing charm. Coffey's pianism had strength and stylistic aplomb." - Chamber music concert for the Mozart Society of California

"That this critically acclaimed keyboard artist makes our community her home and offers her considerable talents so generously counts as one of our region's musical blessings. Coffey's superb pianism and ability to seem graciously at home in a wide variety of performing circumstances has earned her a reputation as both a stellar accompanist and enchanting soloist."
   -   Duo recital with British cellist Rafael Wallfisch
           presented by the Carmel Bach Festival

"Coffey displayed the artistry for which she has built a considerable following, plus enough showmanship to spellbind her audience at least once in each of the concerto's three movements. During those whispered moments a dropped pin would have caused echoes."
    -   Mozart Piano Concerto in E-Flat, with the Monterey Symphony

"Coffey is a sterling performer who has a sure grasp of the capabilities of her instrument. From the opening trill to her final chord, she was the picture of assured virtuosity and fine-drawn musicality. Her playing brought out an extensive, inward and thoughtful exposure of depths of eloquence. Coffey and the orchestra received a standing, cheerful ovation."
    -  Mozart Piano Concerto in E-Flat, with the Monterey Symphony